🇺🇸 Catch Us at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in Lake Barrington, IL 🇺🇸 We Will Offer Larger Outdoor Related Items There! 🇺🇸

Entire Collection

Toad Tackle's Entire Collection of New, Used, Collectible, & Discontinued Fishing Lures & Gear!
1332 products
  • BAGLEY LURES DIVING SMOO 5 Wood Fishing Lure in BLACK TIGER STRIPE on FLUORESCENT GREEN CHARTREUSE
    Bagley Bait Company
    $64.00 CAD
    $64.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY DIVING SMOO Musky Fishing Lure in ORIGINAL TIGER STRIPE on FLUORESCENT YELLOW
    Bagley Bait Company
    $107.00 CAD
    $107.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES DIVING SMOO 5 Fishing Lure in DARK CRAYFISH on CHARTREUSE
    Bagley Bait Company
    $64.00 CAD
    $64.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • old musky jitterbug fishing lure
    Fred Arbogast
    $117.00 CAD
    $117.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Top View of MUSKY SIZED LEGEND LURES Super Eye Popper Fishing Lure • FROG SPOT
    Legend Lures
    $107.00 CAD
    $107.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of MUSKY SIZED MATT LURES SLOW SINKING SWIMBAIT Fishing Lure
    Matt Lures
    $156.00 CAD
    $156.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • SPRO Musky Sized RAT 50 Fishing Lure in GREY GHOST
    Spro Corp
    $57.00 CAD
    $57.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • SPRO Musky Sized Wake Bait. RAT 50 Fishing Lure in WHITE.
    Spro Corp
    $107.00 CAD
    $107.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Antique Practice Plug. NASAC FISHING CASTING PLUG. logo
    National Association of Scientific Angling Club
    $25.00 CAD
    $25.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • 1976-2004 NFLCC Show Pin CREEL & WOODEN REEL
    NFLCC
    $11.00 CAD
    $11.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of BRIAN'S BEES CRANKBAITS Handmade 4
    Brian's Bees Crankbaits
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BRIGHT LIVER TACKLE Japan FREDDIE STAGE 2 FISHING LURE. N-GBT. ブライトリバー
    BrightLiver Tackle
    $78.00 CAD
    $78.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Original STORM LURES BUG PLUG Fishing Lure in METALLIC SILVER BACK
    Storm Lures
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES GLR-15 GLIDIN' RAP Fishing Lure in PEARL SHAD
    Rapala
    $57.00 CAD
    $57.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES ThunderMac Fishing Lure in SILVER SCALE
    Storm
    $46.00 CAD
    $46.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Phoney Frogs USA CRAWFISH CHATTER BAIT. Virginia Handmade Fishing Lure. Rusty Olive Craw. L
    PhoneyFrogsUSA
    $178.00 CAD
    $178.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Phoney Frogs USA CRAWFISH CHATTER BAIT. Virginia Handmade Fishing Lure.
    PhoneyFrogsUSA
    $178.00 CAD
    $178.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Phoney Frogs USA CRAWFISH CHATTER BAIT. Virginia Custom Made Fishing Lure. Yellow Craw.
    PhoneyFrogsUSA
    $178.00 CAD
    $178.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • MANNS BAITS SUPER STRETCH 1- Big Fish Jerkbait in GREEN SHAD CHARTREUSE side view
    Mann's Bait Company
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. YY2 CRAW.
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of National Fishing Lure Collectors Club 2008 CLUB LURE • NFLCC Commemorative Fishing Lure • REND LAKE BASS
    NFLCC
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NFLCC PAW PAW BAIT COMPANY WOTTAFROG Patch
    NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NFLCC (National Fishing Lure Collectors Club) CREEK CHUB BEETLE Fishing Lure Collector's Patch
    NFLCC
    $29.00 CAD
    $29.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of NFLCC Fred Arbogast Tin Liz Sunfish 1976-1996 Collector Fishing Patch
    NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of NFLCC National Fishing Lure Collector's Club Patch • 1993 FRED ARBOGAST JITTERBUG
    NFLCC
    $29.00 CAD
    $29.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NFLCC PREMIERE EDITION FISHING PATCH • Antique SHAKESPEARE REVOLUTION LURE
    NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NATIONAL FISHING LURE COLLECTORS CLUB SHOW Pin Antique Wood Bobbers
    NFLCC
    $10.00 CAD
    $10.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NATIONAL FISHING LURE COLLECTORS CLUB SHOW Pin Button • NFLCC NEW YORK BUEL LURE.
    NFLCC
    $10.00 CAD
    $10.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of National Fishing Lure Collector Club Embroidered Sticker Patches • 4 Count NFLCC Souvenir Collectible
    NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of NATIONAL FISHING LURE COLLECTORS CLUB TACKLE COLLECTORS PATCH • ANTIQUE WOOD BOBBERS
    NFLCC
    $18.00 CAD
    $18.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of NFLCC's NATIONAL FISHING LURE COLLECTORS CLUB ANNIVERSARY PATCH • 1976-1996 FROG on TOADSTOOL
    NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • NFLCC
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out