🇺🇸 Catch Us at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in Lake Barrington, IL 🇺🇸 We Will Offer Larger Outdoor Related Items There! 🇺🇸

New Stock

New, Used, Old, Antique, Vintage, Discontinued, & Collectible Fishing Gear!

If You Missed Our NEW STOCK Stories on Instagram or Facebook...You Can Find Out Here!   •Changes Monthly•

Follow Us on Twitter for Our eBay Store Updates Too!

If You Check This Page Often, Make Sure You Look at All Pages. Sometimes Listings are Made Months Ahead of Time & Will Appear as Our Oldest Listings When, In Fact, Were Launched That Very Day

153 products
  • FRED ARBOGAST FIREPLUG JITTERBUG ANTIQUE Fishing Lure in SATURN GREEN R
    Fred Arbogast
    $65.00 USD
    $65.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEYS DIVING BANG-O-B 8 BALSA FISHING LURE in HOT BLUE CHARTREUSE on SILVER FOIL
    Jim Bagley Bait Company
    $27.00 USD
    $27.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Subwart Wake Bait. Bass Fishing Lure.
    Storm Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BOB SZCZESNY CUSTOM WOOD FISHING LURE SET. THE NATURAL
    Bob Szczesny
    $500.00 USD
    $500.00 USD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES RATTLIN FAT RAP 5 Fishing Lure in HOT MUSTARD
    Rapala Lures
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES RATTLIN FAT RAP 4 Fishing Lure in FIRETIGER
    Rapala Lures
    $16.00 USD
    $16.00 USD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES FAT RAP 5 Fishing Lure in GOLD. Silver Plated Edition.
    Rapala Lures
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • seeins believin chipmunk clear lip jitterbug from fred arbogast
    Fred Arbogast
    $53.00 USD
    $53.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Cate Lucky Man Baits Micro Candy Stiks. Magnetic closure box
    Cates Lucky Man Baits
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM WEE WART Custom Painted Crankbait in BUBBLEGUM
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM FATSO Custom Painted Crankbait in BUBBLEGUM
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • CCBCO Straight Pikie Minnow Wood Fishing Lure. Husky Pikie 2300 Series. Rainbow.
    The Creek Chub Bait Company
    $100.00 USD
    $100.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LUHR JENSEN 1/4 oz SPEED TRAP FISHING LURE in SILVER BLACK R
    Luhr Jensen
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BEAVER LAKE 1970 LUNKER AWARD BASS CLUB TROPHY PATCH
    Beaver Lake Bass Club
    $14.00 USD
    $14.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Top Water Junky Japan Custom Bass Fishing Lure. Fat Boy in Box.
    Top Water Junky
    $125.00 USD
    $125.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Top Water Junky Japan Custom Bass Fishing Lure. Drop Rat in Box. Redwing Backbird
    Top Water Junky
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Manns Tiny S 1 Minus. Wounded Alewife Holographic Ultra Light Crankbait. R
    Mann's Bait Company
    $16.00 USD
    $16.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Lures Blue Fade Wiggle Wart. v213 is a Rare Color Find. R
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL SOLID BLACK 8000 SERIES BIG-O CRANKBAIT
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $40.00 USD
    $40.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Wes England We Bait. Handmade Balsa Crankbait. Gold Foil.
    Wes England
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • YY2 YELLOW CRAWDAD. COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. R
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • YY2 WHITE CRAWDAD. COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. R
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. YY2 CRAW.
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART 5. GREEN SHAD Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $28.00 USD
    $28.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Subwart 7 Wake Bait in Shad R
    Storm Lures
    $32.50 USD
    $32.50 USD
    Sold out
  • Rare BAGLEY BAITS BANG-O-B 8 Jerkbait in BLACK STRIPES on ORANGE. big fish fishing lure. R
    Bagley Bait Company
    $60.00 USD
    $60.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BLACK DOG BAITS LUNKER PUNKER BLUEGILL SWIMBAIT boxed
    Black Dog Bait Co.
    $300.00 USD
    $300.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BLACK DOG BAITS LUNKER PUNKER TROUT SWIMBAIT
    Black Dog Bait Co.
    $350.00 USD
    $350.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Gary DeeS Custom Balsa Crankbait. Handmade Gold Foil Lure. R
    Gary Dee Lures
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BIG O 7800 SERIES CRANK. ARKANSAS SHAD GRIP LIP from COTTON CORDELL.
    Cotton Cordell
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • OLD ARBOGAST WOOD JITTERBUG Fishing Lure. Antique WWII BUG in PERCH. R
    Fred Arbogast
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY FISHING LURES DIVING Killer B2 in TRUE LIFE STRIPER on WHITE R
    Jim Bagley Bait Company
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BWCA ELY, MINNESOTA Patch
    Boundary Waters Canoe Area
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BWCA CANOE PORTAGE Collector Souvenir Patch
    Boundary Waters Canoe Area
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES RATTLE TOT Fishing Lure in SOLID CHARTREUSE
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • ANTIQUE HEDDON DOWAGIAC HI-TAIL FISHING LURE R
    Heddon Dowagiac
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL JAPAN POMPADOUR JR FLOATING CRAWLER. GREEN FROG.
    Jackall Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL POMPADOUR JR FLOATING CRAWLER. JAPAN. BLOODY CORE.
    Jackall Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LIVE TARGET EMERALD SHINER BAITBALL SUSPENDING JERKBAIT
    Koppers Fishing & Tackle Corporation
    $21.50 USD
    $21.50 USD
    Sold out
  • Chicago Dogs Scout Night BSA Patch
    Chicago Dogs
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out