🇺🇸 LATEST UPDATE 10/2/2026 ⭐️ $7.50 FLAT USA SHIPPING ⭐️ SHOP HOP THIS WEEKEND at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM BOOTH in LAKE BARRINGTON, IL 🇺🇸

Used, Discontinued, Unique, Collectible, Vintage, & New Fishing Gear

Who Are We? We are Collectors. We Collect Cool Stuff. And the Majority of That is Fishing Lures. Some Old, Some New.

We Collect So Much We Decided to Go Legit. So This is Our Little Corner of the Internet Showcasing Our Passion.

Toad Tackle Offers Hard-To-Find Lures & Ephemera Because...

"They Don't Make 'Em Like They Used To"

Our Stock is Updated Weekly — Check Out Our Instagram & FaceBook Accounts for Our GrassRoots Attempts at Marketing! (that's entertainment worth watching!)

NEW STOCK COLLECTION
Toad Tackle Logo • Red Fire Bellied Toad Holding Fishing Hook Lure • Antique Discontinued Vintage Fishing Lures

New This Month

  • world championship muskie classic. Manitowish Water, WI. Boulder Junction, WI. Winchester, WI. Presque Isle, WI.
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • REBEL LURES CRICKHOPPER Ultralight Crankbait. BLACK CRICKET
    $15.50 USD
    $15.50 USD
    Sold out
  • ANTIQUE HEDDON CRAZY CRAWLER. TRANSITIONAL HARDWARE & SURFACE HARDWARE. James Heddon's Sons Box Marked 2120 GM GREY MOUSE.
    $80.00 USD
    $80.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BILL DANCE PRO AUTOGRAPH SERIES. EXCALIBUR + BOMBER FAT
    $21.00 USD
    $21.00 USD
    Sold out
  • EXCALIBUR FISHING TACKLE and BILL DANCE SUSPENDING FAT FREE SHAD. GREEN SHAD.
    $17.50 USD
    $17.50 USD
    Sold out
  • EXCALIBUR TACKLE & BILL DANCE SPIT N IMAGE JR. TENNESSEE SHAD.
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • EXCALIBUR BILL DANCE GHOST MINNOW TRACDOWN MINNOW. BROWN TROUT
    $15.50 USD
    $15.50 USD
    Sold out
  • MANN'S BAITS SUPER STRETCH 1- JERKBAIT. FIRE TIGER S 1-.
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY'S DEEP DIVING TECHNICAL KNOCKOUT 5 CRANKBAIT. RED HEAD ON WHITE. TKO5DD RHW.
    $90.00 USD
    $90.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY BAITS DEEP DIVING TECHNICAL KNOCKOUT 5 BALSA CRANKBAIT. TKO5DD SH4. SHAD ON WHITE.
    $80.00 USD
    $80.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY'S DEEP DIVING TECHNICAL KNOCKOUT FISHING LURE. BLACK on SILVER FOIL. TKO5DD BS
    $75.00 USD
    $75.00 USD
    Sold out
  • MANN'S BAIT COMPANY WAKER ELITE Fishing Lure. AURORA BLACK. AMERICAN MADE.
    $22.50 USD
    $22.50 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY BAITS TECHNICAL KNOCKOUT 5 FISHING LURE in HOT TIGER. TKO5 H69T
    $125.00 USD
    $125.00 USD
    Sold out
  • MEPPS DRESSED AGLIA SALESMAN SAMPLE RING. Size 0-5 SPINNER BLADES. HFT + RBT
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY BAITS TECHNICAL KNOCKOUT 5 in HOT TIGER. Deep Diver.
    $75.00 USD
    $75.00 USD
    Sold out
View all