⭐️ LATEST LURE DROP on 1/9/2026 ⭐️ WE ARE ALSO EXPANDING OUR VENDOR BOOTH THIS NEXT WEEK at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in LAKE BARRINGTON, IL ⭐️

Used, Discontinued, Unique, Collectible, Vintage, & New Fishing Gear

Who Are We? We are Collectors. We Collect Cool Stuff. And the Majority of That is Fishing Lures. Some Old, Some New.

We Collect So Much We Decided to Go Legit. So This is Our Little Corner of the Internet Showcasing Our Passion.

Toad Tackle Offers Hard-To-Find Lures & Ephemera Because...

"They Don't Make 'Em Like They Used To"

Our Stock is Updated Weekly — Check Out Our Instagram & FaceBook Accounts for Our GrassRoots Attempts at Marketing! (that's entertainment worth watching!)

NEW STOCK COLLECTION
Toad Tackle Logo • Red Fire Bellied Toad Holding Fishing Hook Lure • Antique Discontinued Vintage Fishing Lures

New This Month

  • Heddon Lures Super Sonic. Old Bait. RED WHITE, 9385 RH.
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • $71.00 CAD
    $71.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Heddon Lures Super Sonic. Old Bait. Yellow. 9385 Y
    $22.00 CAD
    $22.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • HEDDON TINY TADPOLLY CLATTERTAD GLO GREEN ALEWIFE Variation. Phosphorescent Series.
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • HEDDON TINY TADPOLLY CLATTERTAD GREEN CRAWDAD. 0990 GR
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • VINTAGE TRAVEL SOUVENIR from SEWARD ALASKA. JUMPING SALMON PIN
    $15.00 CAD
    $15.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • SEBILE PROPPLER 80 FL BUZZ BAIT. White Mouse.
    $36.00 CAD
    $36.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BLOODSHOT MORGUE WOOD CHUGGER FISHING LURE. Color Number 7
    $64.00 CAD
    $64.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • AT TRAIL PATCH. 14 STATE CHALLENGE
    $15.00 CAD
    $15.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • WUPATKI NATIONAL MONUMENT PATCH. Near Flagstaff AZ
    $15.00 CAD
    $15.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Toad Tackle DNR Logo Fishing Sticker
    $5.00 CAD
    $5.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Old Fishing Lure Bass Bird. Topwater Bait from Illinois. Yellow & Brown
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Old Fishing Lure Bass Bird. Topwater Bait from Illinois. Yellow & Black
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Old Fishing Lure Bass Bird. Topwater Bait from Illinois. BlackBird
    $43.00 CAD
    $43.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • FRED ARBOGAST PHRED'S SHADEAUX WOOD FISHING LURE. RAINBOW TROUT
    $31.00 CAD
    $31.00 CAD
    Sold out
View all