🇺🇸 HAPPY 250th USA!! ⭐️ LATEST LURE DROP on 7/12/2026 ⭐️ SEE OUR VINTAGE BOOTH at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in LAKE BARRINGTON, IL ⭐️ Are We a LEGIT Website? HECK YEAH! — see IG/FB 🇺🇸

Entire Collection

Toad Tackle's Entire Collection of New, Used, Collectible, & Discontinued Fishing Lures & Gear!
1399 products
  • BAGLEY LURES MIGHTY MINNOW Fishing Lure in RAINBOW TROUT. Balsa Wood Crankbait.
    Bagley Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Fishing Lure in Fluo GREEN on CHARTREUSE. A Salmon Snack!
    Bagley Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Balsa Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE ON CHROME. Salmon Snack Series
    Bagley Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in GREEN SCALE. Model V 6 Red Label Box
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL 7800 Series BIG O Fishing Lure in NATURAL CHARTREUSE CRAW. Tough Color Find.
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES DT6. DIVES TO 6 FEET Fishing Lure in CRAWDAD
    Rapala
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • BURROUGHS AQUA BAT Antique Fishing Lure with Retro Box and Aqua Tabs
    F.S. Burroughs & Co.
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • LUCKY CRAFT SKT MINI DR Fishing Lure in MAD CRAWR
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • HEDDON MEADOW MOUSE Fishing Lure on Card in YELLOW TIGER
    Heddon Lures
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • FRED ARBOGAST 5/8 oz PLASTIC LIP JITTERBUG Fishing Lure in YELLOW WHITE HERRINGBONE. Japan Special.
    Fred Arbogast
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View for Handmade Wood
    "O" Ridge
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • LUCKY CRAFT Virtual Baits KINGYO KOAKA 40S Fishing Lure in PANDA
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • LUCKY CRAFT Virtual Baits KINGYO KOAKA 40F Fishing Lure in ROKURIN
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of REBEL LURES S76 SINKING WEE CRAWFISH Fishing Lure in SOFTSHELL CRAWFISH
    Rebel/PRADCO
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of REBEL LURES SINKING WEE CRAWFISH Fishing Lure in SHRIMP CRAWFISH
    Rebel/PRADCO
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • FRED ARBOGAST 5/8 oz JITTERSTICK Fishing Lure w/ Box & Pocket Catalog in FROG
    Fred Arbogast
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Boxed View of FRED ARBOGAST 5/8 oz JITTERSTICK Fishing Lure w/ Box & Pocket Catalog in YELLOW
    Fred Arbogast
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES DOWN DEEP RATTLIN FAT RAP 7 Fishing Lure in CHROME
    Rapala Lures
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES RATTLIN FAT RAP 4 Fishing Lure in ORANGE CRAWDAD
    Rapala Lures
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • MEGABASS XJ-100 Fishing Lure with ITÖ ENGINEERING in MAT TIGER
    Megabass
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • MEGABASS POP X Topwater Fishing Lure in GG PEACOCK
    Megabass
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Cover Photo for STORM LURES BABY THUNDERSTICK Fishing Lure in METALLIC GOLD/CHARTREUSE SPECKS
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of National Fishing Lure Collectors Club 2008 CLUB LURE • NFLCC Commemorative Fishing Lure • REND LAKE BASS
    NFLCC
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of BAGLEY Killer B2 Square Bill Fishing Lure in NEON
    Bagley Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Yo-Zuri DUEL HARDCORE SH-50 F Fishing Lure, PRO TUNED MODEL
    Duel Hardcore
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front View of 1949 SOUTH BEND BAIT COMPANY Vintage CATALOG
    South Bend Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front Package View of GAPEN Company WALK-N-LIZARD Wood Musky Sized Fishing Lure in PATTERN YELLOW PERCH
    The Gapen Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front Package View of FISH-ON LURES HAMMERHEAD WOOD MUSKY FISHING LURE in TIGER PATTERN
    Fish On Lures
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Package View of LUCKY CRAFT FAT CB SR Fishing Lure • FALL CRAW Wakebait w/ Square Lip
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front Package View of LUCKY CRAFT FAT CB SR Fishing Lure • CHARTREUSE BLUE
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Front Package View of Handmade Bass Lures BRIAN's BEES CRANKBAITS BABY BEE Fishing Lure in SPRING CRAW
    Brian's Bees Crankbaits
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out
  • Bagley BANG-O 4 with Transitional Hardware Fishing Lure in BLACK on COPPER FOIL Online at Toad Tackle
    Jim Bagley Bait Company
    $50.00 CAD
    $50.00 CAD
    Sold out