Collection: Handcrafted Baits

Artisan Balsa , Wood, & Metal Baits. Handcrafted for the Fisherman Looking to Set His Game Apart From the Crowd. 

47 products
  • PREMIUM HANDCRAFTED BALSA • PH CUSTOM LURES LIL HUNTER 🇺🇸 AMERICAN MADE 🇺🇸 Fishing Lure • COPPER RED
    PH (PHIL HUNT) CUSTOM LURES LIL HUNTER Fishing Lure in COPPER RED
    Vendor
    PH CUSTOM LURES
    Regular price
    $22.50 USD
    Sale price
    $22.50 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • GREAT BRITAIN • ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS • ACE WOBBLIN' FLIPPER
    ACE WOBBLIN FLIPPER Glide Bait. ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS.
    Vendor
    ACE Handcrafted Fishing Lures
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • HollyWOOD LURES Handmade Balsa Fishing Lure • CUSTOM GLIDE BAIT by CLIFF PACE
    HollyWOOD LURES Handmade Balsa Fishing Lure. CUSTOM WOOD GLIDE BAIT by Cliff Pace.
    Vendor
    HollyWOOD Lures
    Regular price
    $90.00 USD
    Sale price
    $90.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • TATER HOG CUSTOM CRAFTED LURES 6.5" SWIMBAIT FISHING LURE • OG SHAD
    TATER HOG CUSTOM CRAFTED LURES SWIMBAIT FISHING LURE. Signed
    Vendor
    Tater Hog Custom Crafted Lures
    Regular price
    $250.00 USD
    Sale price
    $250.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • ALZ BAITS • FRIENDLY AL TUMAS 10.5" JOINTED WOOD MUSKY w/ GLASS EYES Fishing Lure • MINOCQUA, WISCONSIN
    Al Tumas Custom Wood Fishing Lure. Jointed Muskie Bait from the Musky Capital World of the World: Minocqua, Wisconsin. ALZ BAITS for Big Trophy Fish.
    Vendor
    Al Tumas of Alz Baits
    Regular price
    $100.00 USD
    Sale price
    $100.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • JITTERBUG-LIKE LIP • CUSTOM MADE WOOD MUSKY Fishing Lure • PERCH SCALE
    Right Facing View for CUSTOM MADE WOOD MUSKY Fishing Lure. Topwater Bait with Jitterbug Lip.
    Vendor
    Unknown/Unidentified
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, ILLINOIS • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood MUSKY Fishing Lure w/ Glass Eyes & Brass Lip • 5" FIRE TIGER
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood MUSKY Fishing Lure in FIRE TIGER R
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • GREAT BRITAIN • ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS • TOPWATER
    Right Facing View of ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS of Great Britain. Topwater Musky Baits For Sale at Toad Tackle.
    Vendor
    ACE Handcrafted Fishing Lures
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • GREAT BRITAIN • ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS • ACE PERCH LURE
    ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS of Great Britain. Musky Size ACE PERCH LURE For Sale at Toad Tackle.
    Vendor
    ACE Handcrafted Fishing Lures
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • GREAT BRITAIN • ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS • SMALL SCUD GLIDE BAIT
    ACE HANDCRAFTED FISHING LURES by GORDON GRIFFITHS. SMALL SCUD Musky GLIDE BAIT
    Vendor
    ACE Handcrafted Fishing Lures
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • THE ORIGINAL TENNESSEE SHAD SQUARE LIP Fishing Lure • ORANGE w/ BLACK BACK
    Right Facing View of ORIGINAL TENNESSEE SHAD SQUARE LIP Fishing Lure in ORANGE w/ BLACK BACK. Handmade Balsa Crankbait.
    Vendor
    Tennessee Shad Corporation
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" YELLOW & RED PERCH SCALE
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" YELLOW w/ DOTS & BLACK BACK
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" RED HEAD
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 5
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" BLACK
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 5
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • OAKRIDGE, TENNESSEE • "O" RIDGE Balsa Wood Vintage Fishing Lure • BLUE, GREEN w/ YELLOW BELLY
    Right Facing View for Handmade Wood
    Vendor
    "O" Ridge
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • KOUTS, INDIANA • MITCHEZ BAIT COMPANY Handcrafted 7" Wood Fishing Lure • 3 Hook PERCH SCALE
    MITCHEZ BAIT COMPANY of Indiana 7
    Vendor
    Mitchez Bait Company
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • LAKE OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA • SAM GRIFFIN Collectible Wood Fishing Lure • WOOD TRAP #2
    Right Facing View of SAM GRIFFIN of Lake Okeechobee, Florida WOOD TRAP #2 Fishing Lure
    Vendor
    Sam Griffin
    Regular price
    $25.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Topwater Plug Fishing Lure • 5" PERCH SCALE
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 5
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 6 1/4" PERCH SCALE
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 6 1/4
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 8 1/2" BLACK 3-HOOK
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 8 1/2
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" PERCH SCALE
      NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 5
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 6 1/4" PIKE SCALE
    Right Facing View of NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 6 1/4
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 5" SHAD SCALE w/ BLACK BACK
      NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 5
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Arlington Heights, Illinois • NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY Handcrafted Wood Fishing Lure • 4" BLACK
    NU-CLASSIC TACKLE COMPANY 4
    Vendor
    Nu-Classic Tackle
    Regular price
    $35.00 USD
    Sale price
    $35.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • PAUL CROWE HANDCRAFTED 2" Shallow Diver FISHING LURE 🇺🇸 KOKOMO, INDIANA 🇺🇸
    Right Facing View of PAUL CROWE HANDCRAFTED 2
    Vendor
    Paul Crowe
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $20.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Danielsville, Georgia • SUDDETH LITTLE BOSS HAWG RATTLIN Fishing Lure • YELLOW w/ BLACK BACK
    Right Facing View of SUDDETH LITTLE BOSS HAWG RATTLIN Fishing Lure From Danielsville, Georgia in YELLOW w/ BLACK BACK
    Vendor
    Blademaster Lures, Inc
    Regular price
    $17.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Deep Diver Fishing Lure • OLIVE GREEN CRAW/BLUE FLAKE
    Right Facing View of C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Deep Diver Fishing Lure in OLIVE GREEN CRAW/BLUE FLAKE
    Vendor
    C-Flash Baits
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Square Bill Fishing Lure • OLIVE BACK/BLUE SHAD/SHELL PINK BELLY
    Right Facing View of C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Square Bill  Fishing Lure in OLIVE BACK/BLUE SHAD
    Vendor
    C Flash Baits
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Square Bill Fishing Lure • OLIVE GREEN CRAW/BLUE FLAKE
    Vendor
    C Flash Baits
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Square Bill Fishing Lure • MUSTARD SHAD
    Right Facing View of C-FLASH CRANKBAITS Handcrafted Square Bill Fishing Lure in MUSTARD SHAD
    Vendor
    C-Flash Baits
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • MUSKITA BAITS & TACKLE • Artist Signed THE ARTISTIC SUNFISH Fishing Lure (2002) • 1000 Islands — NY & Ontario • #290-AS-BT
    Boxed View of MUSKITA BAITS & TACKLE THE ARTISTIC SUNFISH Fishing Lure from 2002
    Vendor
    Muskita Baits & Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • MUSKITA BAITS & TACKLE • Artist Signed SPINNING MOUSE Fishing Lure • 1000 Islands — NY & Ontario • #324-BGMF-P
    Box Lid View of MUSKITA BAITS & TACKLE SPINNING MOUSE Fishing Lure
    Vendor
    Muskita Baits & Tackle
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • HANDMADE WOOD CRANKBAIT Fishing Lure From DOUBLE-R-LURES of ELLWOOD CITY, PENNSYLVANIA • #882 FROG
    Right Facing View of HANDMADE WOOD CRANKBAIT Fishing Lure From DOUBLE-R-LURES of ELLWOOD CITY, PENNSYLVANIA. For Sale Online at Toad Tackle.
    Vendor
    Double-R-Lures, Pennsylvania
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • FISHING LURE HISTORIAN • MARTY'S YANKEE DOODLE DANDY "FROGGISH" Fishing Lure Handmade by MARK M. DEVLIN JR • JULY 4th, 2000
    Right Facing View of MARTY'S YANKEE DOODLE DANDY
    Vendor
    MARK M. DEVLIN JR
    Regular price
    $50.00 USD
    Sale price
    $50.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • FISHING LURE HISTORIAN • FROGGISH Fishing Lure Handmade by MARK M. DEVLIN JR • USA 3 HOOK
    Top View of USA Flag FROGGISH Fishing Lure Handmade by MARK M. DEVLIN JR. Available at Toad Tackle.
    Vendor
    Mark M. Devlin Jr.
    Regular price
    $50.00 USD
    Sale price
    $50.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Collector Piece From SAM GRIFFIN of Lake Okeechobee, Florida NIPPIN SAM Fishing Lure • SUGAR PINE Nov. 1, 1989
    Box Top View of SAM GRIFFIN of Lake Okeechobee, Florida NIPPIN SAM Sugar Pine Fishing Lure
    Vendor
    Sam Griffin
    Regular price
    $40.00 USD
    Sale price
    $40.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Premium Balsa Bait • BASS CRAFT CRANKBAITS POP N WALK Fishing Lure • BATEY SHAD
    Package Front View of  Handcrafted Balsa BASS CRAFT CRANKBAITS POP N WALK Fishing Lure in BATEY SHAD
    Vendor
    Bass Craft Crankbaits
    Regular price
    $100.00 USD
    Sale price
    $100.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • DYLANEY Inc. C FLASH BAITS 44 CAL Crankbait Fishing Lure • MINT GREEN FOIL
    Package View of USA MADE C-FLASH BAITS 44 CAL Crankbait Fishing Lure in  MINT GREEN FOIL
    Vendor
    Dylaney Inc. C-Flash Baits
    Regular price
    $25.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Original Handmade DAM EFFZETT Nature Gudgeon Fishing Lure • BROWN SUCKER
    Boxed View of Original Handmade DAM EFFZETT Nature Gudgeon Fishing Lure in BROWN SUCKER
    Vendor
    DAM
    Regular price
    $30.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.00 USD
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out