🇺🇸 Catch Us at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in Lake Barrington, IL 🇺🇸 We Will Offer Larger Outdoor Related Items There! 🇺🇸

Entire Collection

Toad Tackle's Entire Collection of New, Used, Collectible, & Discontinued Fishing Lures & Gear!
1336 products
  • BAGLEY LURES MIGHTY MINNOW Fishing Lure in RAINBOW TROUT. Balsa Wood Crankbait.
    Bagley Bait Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LIVE TARGET BAIT BALL Crankbait in METALLIC LIME GREY. Discontinued Koppers Fishing Lure.
    Koppers Fishing & Tackle Corporation
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LIVE TARGET BAIT BALL Crankbait in METALLIC PEARL BLUE SHAD. Discontinued Koppers Fishing Lure.
    Koppers Fishing & Tackle Corporation
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE FLUORESCENT RED HERRINGBONE. Vintage Deep Diver Crankbait. R
    Storm Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • TICKLED PINK HEDDON MAGNUM CLATTERTAD TADPOLLY Fishing Lure
    Heddon
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • RIVER 2 SEA DRAGON FLY POP 70 Topwater Fishing Lure with Daiichi Hooks
    River2Sea
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rare Color BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Balsa Fishing Lure in Black on Red. Salmon Snack. R
    Bagley Bait Company
    $40.00 USD
    $40.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART Size 5 Fishing Lure in GREEN FROG
    Storm Lures
    $40.00 USD
    $40.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LIVE TARGET THREADFIN SHAD BAIT BALL Crankbait Fishing Lure in PEARL VIOLET SHAD
    Koppers Fishing & Tackle Corporation
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Antique Practice Plug. NASAC FISHING CASTING PLUG. logo
    National Association of Scientific Angling Club
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LYMAN LURES SIZE 4 CEDAR WOOD FISHING LURE in GLOW. Trolling Bait for Salmon and Trout.
    Lyman Lures
    $75.00 USD
    $75.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES MID WART 5 Fishing Lure in BASS. Mid Runner Crankbait for Largemouth Bass & Trophy Predator Fish!
    Storm Lures
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • National Hockey League CHICAGO BLACKHAWKS BOY SCOUTS DAY Embroidered Patch. SHOW YOUR COLORS.
    Chicago Blackhawks
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • XCALIBUR Fishing Tackle XR50 Lipless Crankbait in FOXY MOMMA R
    XCalibur Tackle Company
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WW0538 N NNSN O SPECIAL EDITION WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure
    Storm Lures
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • XCALIBUR HI-TEK TACKLE XR75 Lipless Crankbait in GHOST. High Vibrating Bass Fishing Lure.
    XCalibur
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • REBEL LURES FASTRAC JOINTED MINNOW Vintage Fishing Lure in SILVER BLACK
    Rebel Lures
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL LURES ASKA 70 SR Fishing Lure in SUPER CRAWFISH
    Jackall Lures
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL LURES ASKA 60 SR Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE SHAD
    Jackall Lures
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Megabass USA
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WEE WART Fishing Lure in NATURISTIC GREEN CRAYFISH. Older Red Label Box
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Fishing Lure in Fluo GREEN on CHARTREUSE. A Salmon Snack!
    Bagley Bait Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Lures Clear Lip Wiggle Wart Fishing Lure in NATURISTIC GREEN CRAYFISH
    Storm Lures
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Balsa Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE ON CHROME. Salmon Snack Series
    Bagley Bait Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in PURPLE SCALE. Model V 1 Red Label Box
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in GREEN SCALE. Model V 6 Red Label Box
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • THE DYN-O-MITE LURE CO NON- EXPLOSIVE DYNAMITE Fishing Lure with REPLACEMENT FUSES. Novelty Bait from Lakeview, Iowa, for Birthday or Christmas Gifts!
    The Dyn-O-Mite Lure Co
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • MANNS BAITS SOFT PLASTIC JELLY WORM Fishing Lure Salesman Sample.
    Mann's Bait Company
    $9.99 USD
    $9.99 USD
    Sold out
  • BANDIT LURES 400 SERIES Crankbait Fishing Lure in SILVER MINNOW with Triple Grip Hooks
    Bandit Lures
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BANDIT LURES 400 SERIES Crankbait Fishing Lure in FIRE TIGER with Triple Grip Hooks
    Bandit Lures
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • GEORGIA KILLER Little Killer Wood Fishing Lure. Handmade Flat Balsa Bait by LONNIE MELTON of Covington, Georgia. R
    L & M Bait Co | Lonnie Melton
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LUHR JENSEN K16 Kwik Fish Fishing Lure. OLD GLORY Commemorative September 11th Bait.
    Luhr Jensen
    $175.00 USD
    $175.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COOPER LOOR of Chicago, Illinois, Orange FROG Fishing Lure w/ Antique Retro Graphics Box
    Cooper Lures
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Cast-A-Bird Fishing Lure from Newt Inc. of Oconto, Wisconsin. Antique Topwater Bait with Original Snap Box and Marketing Insert.
    Newt Inc
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL 7800 Series BIG O Fishing Lure in NATURAL CHARTREUSE CRAW. Tough Color Find.
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BOMBER BAITS PINFISH Fishing Lure in LIGHT CRAWDAD. Vintage Lipless Crankbait.
    Bomber Bait Company
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BOMBER BAITS PINFISH Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE YELLOW HEAD. Vintage Metaflash Series Lipless Crankbait.
    Bomber Bait Company
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BOMBER BAITS PINFISH Fishing Lure in GOLD BLACK HEAD. Vintage Lipless Crankbait.
    Bomber Bait Company
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out
  • XCALIBUR TUNGSTEN ONE KNOCKER XRK50 Fishing Lure in FOXY SHAD. 5/8 oz Lipless Crankbait.
    XCalibur Tackle Company
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LUHR JENSEN KING SALMON Fishing Patch. Vintage Tournament Fishing Patch.
    Luhr Jensen
    $12.00 USD
    $12.00 USD
    Sold out