🇺🇸 Catch Us at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in Lake Barrington, IL 🇺🇸 We Will Offer Larger Outdoor Related Items There! 🇺🇸

Entire Collection

Toad Tackle's Entire Collection of New, Used, Collectible, & Discontinued Fishing Lures & Gear!
1332 products
  • Rebel Lures
    $12.00 USD
    $12.00 USD
    Sold out
  • 2nd Generation Berkley Frenzy Popper Fishing Lure in RAINBOW TROUT w/ SaltWater Hooks
    Berkley
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rebel Lures
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • HEDDON LURES GO DEEPER MIDGET RIVER RUNT. Antique Fishing Lure from the 1940s! nose
    Heddon Lure Company
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rebel
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of BOMBER BAIT COMPANY MODEL 25 A Fishing Lure in FROG. Vintage Bass Crankbait with Screw Tail.
    Bomber Bait Company
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of BOMBER BAIT COMPANY MODEL 25 A Fishing Lure in GREEN MONKEY PUKE. Screwtail Model Means Older or Vintage Crankbait.
    Bomber Bait Company
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Front View of ANTIQUE FISHING POSTCARD. Available at Toad Tackle.
    National Post Card Service
    $10.00 USD
    $10.00 USD
    Sold out
  • seeins believin chipmunk clear lip jitterbug from fred arbogast
    Fred Arbogast
    $53.00 USD
    $53.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rebel Lures
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • REBEL LURES F62 FLOATER Vintage Fishing Lure in RED BACK or Fluorescent Pink
    Rebel Lures
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Antique Shakespeare Fishing Lures Jumping Bass Calendar 1941. Sporting Goods Store Advertising Signs for Fishermen.
    Shakespeare Company
    $250.00 USD
    $250.00 USD
    Sold out
  • SHAKESPEARE SPECIAL Vintage Topwater Fishing Lure with Original Vintage Box in SILVER FLASH
    Shakespeare
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out
  • SHAKESPEARE SPORTING GOODS Bait Shop Envelope. FISHING EPHEMERA with VINTAGE GRAPHICS
    Shakespeare
    $7.50 USD
    $7.50 USD
    Sold out
  • Rare Color BAGLEY LURES BASS N SHAD Balsa Fishing Lure in Black on Red. Salmon Snack. R
    Bagley Bait Company
    $40.00 USD
    $40.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Grasshopper Wood Decoy Handmade by Artist Jim Smith of Anna, IL. Handcrafted Fishing Art Made of Cedar Wood and Glass Eyes.
    JAS Lures by Jim Smith
    $85.00 USD
    $85.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Jointed Fish Wood Decoy Fishing Lure by Southern Illinois Artist Jim Smith
    JAS Lures by Jim Smith
    $80.00 USD
    $80.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Jointed Gar Wood Fishing Lure from Southern Illinois Artist Jim Smith. Fishing Art by JAS Lures. R
    JAS Lures by Jim Smith
    $105.00 USD
    $105.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Mallard Duck Drake Wood Decoy Lure by JAS LURES of Anna, IL. Fishing Art from Southern Illinois Artist Jim Smith.
    JAS Lures by Jim Smith
    $175.00 USD
    $175.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Frog and Fly Wood Decoy Lure by Southern Illinois Artist Jim Smith. Fishing Art from JAS Lures of Anna, IL
    JAS Lures by Jim Smith
    $200.00 USD
    $200.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Side Stamp View of STORM LURES WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in CHARTREUSE
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of STORM LURES Side Stamped WIGGLE WART Fishing Lure in RED SCALE
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $120.00 USD
    $120.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Old School Wiggle Wart with Side Stamp from Storm Fishing Lures. Rare Purple Scale.
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $75.00 USD
    $75.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Custom Painted Heddon Lures Tiny Punkinseed
    Heddon
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rare Sturgeon DFD Wood Decoy. Signed Folk Art Piece by Dave Perkins Duluth Fishing Decoys.
    Duluth Fishing Decoy
    $800.00 USD
    $800.00 USD
    Sold out
  • RAPALA LURES FAT RAP 5 Fishing Lure in GOLD. Silver Plated Edition.
    Rapala Lures
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Rapala
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY LURES MIGHTY MINNOW Fishing Lure in RAINBOW TROUT. Balsa Wood Crankbait.
    Bagley Bait Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LUCKY CRAFT SKT MINI DR Fishing Lure in MAD CRAWR
    Lucky Craft Company, LTD
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of DULUTH FISHING DECOY by JIM PERKINS • AMERICANA FLAG PIKE
    Duluth Fishing Decoy
    $150.00 USD
    $150.00 USD
    Sold out
  • REBEL LURES SHALLOW R SHALLOW Fishing Lure in BROWN ORANGE
    Rebel Lures
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Right Facing View of COTTON CORDELL TOP SPOT Fishing Lure in possibly SMOKEY JOE
    Cotton Cordell
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out