🇺🇸 Catch Us at ALL AMERICAN RECLAIM in Lake Barrington, IL 🇺🇸 We Will Offer Larger Outdoor Related Items There! 🇺🇸

Entire Collection

Toad Tackle's Entire Collection of New, Used, Collectible, & Discontinued Fishing Lures & Gear!
1336 products
  • seeins believin chipmunk clear lip jitterbug from fred arbogast
    Fred Arbogast
    $53.00 USD
    $53.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Cate Lucky Man Baits Micro Candy Stiks. Magnetic closure box
    Cates Lucky Man Baits
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM WEE WART Custom Painted Crankbait in BUBBLEGUM
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM FATSO Custom Painted Crankbait in BUBBLEGUM
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • CCBCO Straight Pikie Minnow Wood Fishing Lure. Husky Pikie 2300 Series. Rainbow.
    The Creek Chub Bait Company
    $100.00 USD
    $100.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LUHR JENSEN 1/4 oz SPEED TRAP FISHING LURE in SILVER BLACK R
    Luhr Jensen
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BEAVER LAKE 1970 LUNKER AWARD BASS CLUB TROPHY PATCH
    Beaver Lake Bass Club
    $14.00 USD
    $14.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Top Water Junky Japan Custom Bass Fishing Lure. Fat Boy in Box.
    Top Water Junky
    $125.00 USD
    $125.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Top Water Junky Japan Custom Bass Fishing Lure. Drop Rat in Box. Redwing Backbird
    Top Water Junky
    $55.00 USD
    $55.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Manns Tiny S 1 Minus. Wounded Alewife Holographic Ultra Light Crankbait. R
    Mann's Bait Company
    $16.00 USD
    $16.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Lures Blue Fade Wiggle Wart. v213 is a Rare Color Find. R
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL SOLID BLACK 8000 SERIES BIG-O CRANKBAIT
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $40.00 USD
    $40.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Wes England We Bait. Handmade Balsa Crankbait. Gold Foil.
    Wes England
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • YY2 YELLOW CRAWDAD. COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. R
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $50.00 USD
    $50.00 USD
    Sold out
  • YY2 WHITE CRAWDAD. COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. R
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • COTTON CORDELL TACKLE 7800 SERIES BIG O CRANKBAIT. YY2 CRAW.
    Cotton Cordell Tackle Company
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART 5. GREEN SHAD Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $28.00 USD
    $28.00 USD
    Sold out
  • Storm Subwart 7 Wake Bait in Shad R
    Storm Lures
    $32.50 USD
    $32.50 USD
    Sold out
  • Rare BAGLEY BAITS BANG-O-B 8 Jerkbait in BLACK STRIPES on ORANGE. big fish fishing lure. R
    Bagley Bait Company
    $60.00 USD
    $60.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BLACK DOG BAITS LUNKER PUNKER BLUEGILL SWIMBAIT boxed
    Black Dog Bait Co.
    $300.00 USD
    $300.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BLACK DOG BAITS LUNKER PUNKER TROUT SWIMBAIT
    Black Dog Bait Co.
    $350.00 USD
    $350.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BIG O 7800 SERIES CRANK. ARKANSAS SHAD GRIP LIP from COTTON CORDELL.
    Cotton Cordell
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • OLD ARBOGAST WOOD JITTERBUG Fishing Lure. Antique WWII BUG in PERCH. R
    Fred Arbogast
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BAGLEY FISHING LURES DIVING Killer B2 in TRUE LIFE STRIPER on WHITE R
    Jim Bagley Bait Company
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BWCA ELY, MINNESOTA Patch
    Boundary Waters Canoe Area
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • BWCA CANOE PORTAGE Collector Souvenir Patch
    Boundary Waters Canoe Area
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES RATTLE TOT Fishing Lure in SOLID CHARTREUSE
    Storm Manufacturing Company
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • ANTIQUE HEDDON DOWAGIAC HI-TAIL FISHING LURE R
    Heddon Dowagiac
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL JAPAN POMPADOUR JR FLOATING CRAWLER. GREEN FROG.
    Jackall Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • JACKALL POMPADOUR JR FLOATING CRAWLER. JAPAN. BLOODY CORE.
    Jackall Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • LIVE TARGET EMERALD SHINER BAITBALL SUSPENDING JERKBAIT
    Koppers Fishing & Tackle Corporation
    $21.50 USD
    $21.50 USD
    Sold out
  • Chicago Dogs Scout Night BSA Patch
    Chicago Dogs
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES MIDWART MID RUNNER CRANKBAIT. NATURISTIC PERCH.
    Storm Lures
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART. SILVER BLUE SHAD. Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART. BROWN FROG. Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $30.00 USD
    $30.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART. GREEN FROG. Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • STORM LURES SUBWART. BUMBLE BEE. Wake Bait. R
    Storm Lures
    $35.00 USD
    $35.00 USD
    Sold out
  • VINTAGE BLACK HILLS TRAVEL SOUVENIR DECAL. RAINBOW TROUT in SPEARFISH, SOUTH DAKOTA.
    Lindgren-Turner Co.
    $10.00 USD
    $10.00 USD
    Sold out
  • VINTAGE CANADA TRAVEL SOUVENIR DECAL. Canadian Geese in Nestor Falls, Ontario.
    Canada DecalCoMania CO. LTD.
    $10.00 USD
    $10.00 USD
    Sold out
  • MANNS BAITS 1- MINUS CRANKBAIT in ALABAMA SHAD R
    Mann's Bait Company
    $18.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
    Sold out